Tracy Johnson, a veteran radio industry expert and author of “Mic Drop Moments: The Playbook For Unforgettable Guest Interviews,” recently shared his wealth of knowledge about conducting compelling podcast interviews on the School of Podcasting. His insights, drawn from decades of experience in the radio industry, offer valuable guidance for podcasters looking to elevate their interview game. If you missed the episode, you can check it out HERE.
The Triple Threat Filter: A Framework for Guest Selection
At the heart of Johnson's approach is what he calls the “Triple Threat Filter,” a systematic way to evaluate potential guests. This framework considers three crucial elements: familiarity, relevance, and entertainment value.
Familiarity speaks to how well-known a guest is to your audience. While being famous doesn't guarantee a great interview, it does provide built-in interest from listeners.
Relevance ensures the guest's story or expertise aligns with your audience's interests and your show's focus.
The entertainment value factor examines whether the guest can tell engaging stories and contribute to an interesting conversation.
Glenn Hebert from the Horse Radio Network was (at the time) unknown to my audience when he first appeared. As his informal was extremely relevant (and valuable) and delivered in an entertaining fashion, he’s been back more than any other guest.
Johnson emphasizes that while a guest doesn't need to excel in all three areas, failing in two out of three categories makes it extremely challenging to create compelling content. He illustrates this with an example of interviewing a local hardware store owner—someone who might not be famous or immediately relevant but could still create engaging content through unexpected stories.
The Art of Entertainment: The Three E's
Johnson shared an fascinating insight from an unlikely source – Tommy Chong – who taught him about the three E's of entertainment: enhance, exaggerate, and embellish. These principles help transform ordinary stories into captivating content while maintaining authenticity.
Enhancement involves adding depth and context to stories, helping listeners better understand and connect with the narrative. Exaggeration helps emphasize key moments and build excitement, though Johnson stresses the importance of maintaining truthfulness. Embellishment involves including relevant details that make the story more vivid and engaging for listeners.
Crafting Better Interviews: Beyond Basic Questions
One of Johnson's most emphatic points was the importance of moving beyond generic, surface-level questions. He strongly advises against opening with tired phrases like “tell us about yourself,” instead encouraging interviewers to dig deeper and find unique angles.
The pre-interview emerges as a crucial tool in Johnson's methodology. This preliminary conversation helps uncover potential “did you hear it?” moments – those golden nuggets of conversation that keep listeners engaged and coming back for more. During the actual interview, Johnson advocates for strategic use of silence, allowing guests space to elaborate and reveal deeper insights.
The Power of Strategic Editing
Johnson emphasized that great interviews often come together in the editing process. He recommends removing anything that doesn't serve the core story while maintaining the authentic moments that make conversations feel real and engaging. The goal is to start strong and maintain momentum throughout the episode.
Handling Challenging Situations with Grace
Perhaps most valuably, Johnson addressed how to handle difficult situations that every interviewer eventually faces. When declining unsuitable guests, he recommends being honest but tactful, explaining why the fit isn't right for your audience. For challenging personalities, thorough preparation becomes your best defense.
The Balance of Authority and Humility
Throughout the conversation, Johnson emphasized the importance of maintaining a delicate balance between confidence and humility as an interviewer. While you need the authority to guide the conversation, remaining humble enough to truly listen and learn from guests is equally crucial.
Making Mic Drop Moments
Johnson's insights remind us that great interviews don't happen by accident. They require careful guest selection, thorough preparation, and strategic execution. The goal isn't simply to have an interesting conversation, but to create content that truly serves and engages your audience while enhancing your show's value.
For those looking to dive deeper into these concepts, Johnson's book “Mic Drop Moments” (available at micdropmoments.net) offers an expanded exploration of these principles and more techniques for creating compelling interview content.
Listen to the episode here. Follow the show and never miss an episode.
